Danish Dari German Spanish French Turkish Arabic
Click here to go to start page Click here to go to start page
Search Sort content by country/region Sort content by artist Sort content by subject
News stories world-wide
News 2011
News 2010
News 2009
News 2008
News 2007
News 2006
News 2005
News 2004
News 2003
News 2002
News 2001
About music censorship
About Freemuse
Publications
Study room
Activities
Links
Press room

NEWS
23 October 2008

China:
Western religious music banned

According to the British newspaper the Telegraph, Western musicians and tour organisers have encountered difficulties with performances in China due to a tightened political control over the arts and Christianity.

Article by: Kristina Funkeson, Freemuse


The victims of the ban are orchestral and choral groups with pieces of a religious nature on their repertoire. For example, the Sinfonica Orchestra di Roma has given up on performing Mozart’s Requiem for a fundraising event in the Sichuan earthquake zone in honour of the dead. Instead the orchestra will play a programme of smaller and mainly non-religious work.

No clear regulations
The Telegraph has not managed to get a comment from the Chinese ministry of culture, but an official said: “It is not a black and white issue, and there is nothing written on paper of in the regulations […] A smaller piece as a part of a bigger programme might be OK, but a big work like Mozart’s Requiem would definitely be out.”

The British Academy of Ancient Music had already, before the crackdown, been invited to sing The Messiah at the Beijing International Music Festival in October. The Telegraph reports that the performance will go ahead as planned, but has been changed to “by invitation only” to get round the ban.

Christianity in China
According to the Telegraph, the attitude among China’s top leadership seems to be divided: “Some regard an explosion in evangelical Christianity across the country as having social benefits, while others regard it as an alien threat to Communist party control.”

The British newspaper the Guardian writes that the Communist Party’s scepticism is due to that Christianity “presented people with an alternative authority (God) and an alternative set of rules”. However, according the Guardian, the spread of Christianity in China is not related to the performances of religious music in concert halls of the cities.

No obvious explanation
Freemuse has previously reported about how the Chinese authorities have tightened the control of foreign artists since about six months back in time. This is thought to be a consequence after the Icelandic singer Björk whispered “Tibet” several times during her song Declare Independence during a concert in Shanghai.

The Telegraph reports that some people also link this new crackdown on Western religious music to Björk’s controversial performance. But according to the Guardian there is no obvious explanation or trigger to the Chinese authorities’ decision to ban Western religious music.




































Secret worship
According to the Guardian, it’s very difficult to estimate the number of Christians in China. Many people worship in secret. It’s estimated to be up to 70 million Christians in China. This is about the same number as members of the Communist Party. The Guardian also writes that it’s also believed that there is a significant overlap in membership of the two groups.


Excerpt of Björk’s concert in Shanghai – video on YouTube






Sources

The Telegraph – 30 September 2008:

‘China bans Western religious music’

The Guardian – 8 October 2008:
‘Switching off church music in China’


Go to top
Related reading on freemuse.org

China / Tibet: How singers sidestep an oppressive law
In a review of a concert by three Tibetan musicians performing in London, Samuel Ivor describes how hidden messages are conveyed in the Tibetan folk music
15 November 2011
Nepal: Police disrupts Tibetan culture show
Tibetans in Nepal are facing increased restrictions on cultural performances. Recently a programme by a Kathmandu-based group was broken up by the Nepalese police
24 October 2011
China: Beijing's censors cancel opera's world premiere
A new opera about Sun Yat-sen, China’s first president, was canceled shortly before its scheduled opening in Beijing because its music allegedly displeased the authorities
12 October 2011
China / Tibet: Young Tibetan singer arrested by Chinese authorities
The singer Hortsang Lhalung Tso is reported to have been detained by Chinese authorities in Tsoe-town of Sangchu county in the Amdho region of eastern Tibet
11 October 2011
China: ‘Super Girl’ music tv-show suspended by government censors
One of China’s most popular televised talent shows, ‘Super Girl’ has been put under yearlong suspension by the State Administration of Radio, Film and Television
21 September 2011
China: 100 songs on culture ministry’s internet blacklist
100 songs that harm ‘national cultural security’ have been placed on an internet blacklist by China’s culture ministry, reported BBC News on 24 August 2011
29 August 2011
China: Controversial rap song banned and deleted from websites
On 29 May 2011 a rap song dedicated to a Mongolian herder who was brutally killed was banned and removed from all Chinese Internet sites immediately after it was posted
10 August 2011
China: Rock musician arrested in airport
The Chinese rock musician Zuoxiao Zuzhou was detained for over 12 hours by police in Shanghai’s airport, a Hong Kong-based rights group said
29 April 2011
China: American folk singer agreed to Chinese censorship
The 69-year-old American folk singer Bob Dylan - famous for his songs against injustice and for civil rights - agreed to perform in China only with a heavily censored list of songs
11 April 2011
China/Tibet: Singer Tashi Dhondup released from prison
The Tibetan singer Tashi Dhondup has been released from prison, reported Radio Free Asia on 8 February 2011
11 February 2011
China: 18th-century German opera censored in Beijing
Zhang Huan’s production of the Handel opera ‘Semele’ concerned Chinese censors. The officials insisted on a number of changes
29 October 2010
China / Tibet: Banned Tibetan singer disappears
Chinese authorities are looking for Pasang, a popular Tibetan singer, who has gone into hiding after his new music album was banned and confiscated
30 September 2010
China / Tibet: Music film about cultural exploitation and resistance
'Tibet in Song' is a tale of cultural exploitation and resistance, which includes the director's own imprisonment for recording the very songs at the centre of the film
24 September 2010
China: Jeroen De Kloet traces the politics of rock in China
Fuelled by the new sounds that entered China's illegal doorways, new bands started to experiment with different sounds.
06 July 2010
China / Tibet: Singer imprisoned for publishing 'subversive songs'
A Chinese court has sentenced the Tibetan singer Tashi Dhondup to one year and seven months’ imprisonment for producing a music album with “subversive songs”
26 April 2010
China: Uncertainty over ban of concerts with American folk singer Bob Dylan
The Chinese government allegedly refused to allow the 68-year-old American folk singer Bob Dylan to perform in Beijing and Shanghai because of his reputation as a protestsinger
07 April 2010
Launch of Freemuse's new report on censorship of heavy metal music
Mark LeVine is online, ready to communicate with you on Facebook and Skype, from 6 PM to 8 PM GMT on Monday 22 February 2010.
17 February 2010
Freemuse report on censorship of heavy metal music
Headbanging against repressive regimes - Censorship of heavy metal in the Middle East, North Africa, Southeast Asia and China. Freemuse report no. 9
25 January 2010
China: Ministry makes new push to control online music
The Chinese ministry of culture implements new censorship rules for online music providers by 1 January 2010 to ensure that lyrics are "acceptable"
05 October 2009
China: Western music industry accepts Chinese censorship
Music banned by the Chinese authorities will not be available at a new free Internet music download service launched earlier this week by Google Inc. and major music companies
15 April 2009